Comments on सुमीर शर्मा हिन्‍दी में: फगवाड़े का फटका (Phagwara Ka Phatka)

Your writing is richer than "lakhon ki dathian". W...

2007-10-05T10:12:00.000+05:30

Your writing is richer than "lakhon ki dathian". While those "Lakhs of rupees" are good only for them, the literature is for everyone.

Gursharn and Harpreet, Thanks for the appreciati...

2007-01-28T20:28:00.000+05:30

Gursharn and Harpreet,

Thanks for the appreciation.

As you can learn from the story, I am from Phillaur.

"ph pha is common among us.

sumir

Read your article, really it is a good one. Keep u...

2007-01-09T01:34:00.000+05:30

Read your article, really it is a good one. Keep up the good work. By the way My Name is Harpreet Parmar, I'm a Chartered Accountant living in Canada (Belong to Phagwara)

u r great man,myself Gursharn Singh From australia...

2006-12-12T10:00:00.000+05:30

u r great man,
myself Gursharn Singh From australia but i belong to phagwara.

Mangla Sahib, Thanks for the appreciation. Kindly ...

2005-10-28T19:29:00.000+05:30

Mangla Sahib,

Thanks for the appreciation.

Kindly tell me how to post in Gurumukhi. I am interested in writing in Punjabi also. I have some story ideas, which people from Punjab region could appreciate. They are about the locales of Punjab. Laxmi Kant has already pointed out that it is bit difficult to understand some expression like the last one "मेनु पदरा कर दिता". Now doubt, it is now challenge for me to put such expressions in a manner that they can have universal appeal. However, I am student of history. I am interested more in writing and reading about history. But my subject imparts me such type of understandings and perceptions which can only be explained and demonstrated through literary writings.

It was Hindi bloggers which kept on prompting me to write in Hindi. It were they who had helped me to make my dream of posting in Hindi a reality. Now, I hope, that I am not demanding much but just persist in adivicing till I am able to post in Punjabi.

Well, I am a great fan of R. D. Burman and O. P. Nayyar the musician. I have great liking for Kishore, Mukesh, Mohammed Rafi, Hemant, S. D. Burman !!!, but on the top of that I like listening to Geeta Bali. I sometime say that even Lata Mangeshkar and Asha Bhonsle remain short of comparison with her.

You are really putting up great compilation. Kindly continue with it. I tell you, such compilation is in great demand. The books which are being published from Meerut and Agra, those Vikrant, Rajan Bedi, Manoj Pocket books stuff, which have remain the interest of Hindi speaking younger generation in comparison to Mills and Bons lot of metropolitian culture, they are publishing such compilation. I once just about to buy a compilation of such songs which were sung by Kishore. However, now through you, I am going to have them free of cost. Aji, Bathroom main dil lag jata agar gana pura atta ho. Warna different songs ka mixture ho jata hai. I am nearing forty now but even then I hum kishore kumar song. Jala jata haon kisi ki dhun me, tadap te dil ke tranai liyea.
Acha, jara aya.

सुमीर, मैं जो कहना चाहता था, वो ख़ुद मानवेन्द्र ने ...

2005-10-28T17:43:00.000+05:30

सुमीर, मैं जो कहना चाहता था, वो ख़ुद मानवेन्द्र ने कह डाला है। वाकई अपने अनुभव को इतने विस्तार से, चौकन्ने होकर और ईमानदारी से बता पाना तो एक छंटे हुए कहानीकार की निशानी है। आपको बहुत बहुत बधाई।

बाकी आपके जैसे अनुभव मेरे भी रहे हैं जर्मनी में पुराने अनपढ़ पंजाबियों को देखकर। हम लोग अपनी पढ़ाई की वजह से अपने instinct और रिस्क लेने की शक्ति खो बैठते हैं। कोई भी काम करने से पहले सौ चीज़ें सोचने लगते हैं।

कुमार मानवेन्द्रThanks for the appreciation. Sumir...

2005-09-29T23:19:00.000+05:30

कुमार मानवेन्द्र
Thanks for the appreciation.
Sumir

बहुत ही जबर्दस्त तरीके से प्रस्तुत किया है आपने एक...

2005-09-29T19:44:00.000+05:30

बहुत ही जबर्दस्त तरीके से प्रस्तुत किया है आपने एक व्यक्ति के मन अन्दर चलने वाले मानसिक द्वंद को। मानसिकता को शब्दों मे पिरा कर उन्हें कलम के जरिये कागज़ पर उतार लेना एक बहुत बडी उपलब्धि है। सच कहुँ तो मै बिलल्कुल कायल हो गया हुँ आपका सिर्फ एक लेख पढ़ कर। लिखते रहिये। कुछ और भी लिखिये, बहुत प्रसंशक मिलेंगे आपको आपकी इन रचनाओं के लिये।